Just like my previous one, this is going to be another Fanfiction recommendation list. If you haven’t read Part 1 yet and are interested in some more yuri recommendations, click here and get redirected to my previous list.
I know, not many people actually read fanfiction, at least if we compare it to the amount of people who watch anime or read manga, but just like doujinshi, many fan works come with a pretty intriguing and great story. In rare cases the fan work even surpasses its original anime or manga, but that’s unfortunately pretty rare, especially when it comes to fanfiction.
So if you’re either new to this or simply looking for something new to read, let me give you some more recommendations of fanfictions, that I especially came to love.
You’ll find stories about the following anime in this list: Shingeki no Kyojin, Mai Hime/Otome and Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha.
Anime: Mai Hime/Otome
Seemingly average Detective Kruger’s world is about to be turned upside down when she meets Windbloom City’s masked heroine, Scarlet Fox. Not only does she have to find out why a mob family is interested in her, but a famous hero and a villain as well.
Genre: Adventure, Comedy, Romance, Superpowers
Pairing: Natsuki x Shizuru (a little bit of Natsuki x Nao)
Status: Ongoing (currently on hold)
ShayP is one of my favorite fanfiction writers, who always comes up with new and fresh ideas for some great stories. After writing a military and a pirate story, ShayP came up with yet another ShizNat fanfiction, this time about superheroes. People who have already read her previous works know that she is a genius when it comes to creating her own fictional worlds and just like in “Monster” and “Siren of the Sea”, ShayP did a fantastic job in adding Natsuki and Shizuru into yet another environment. And I have to say, they fit their new roles surprisingly well.
Anime: Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha (I assume somewhere between A’s and StrikerS)
Author: Tsuyazakura Kouyuki
Title: The Queen of the Evening Skies
It had been six months since Nanoha was stabbed by a Gadget Drone. She had recovered and taken a medical leave of absence to finalize her rehabilitation, which she took advantage of to enjoy the final months of her high school year. Yet life had more cruel surprises in store for her. This time, maybe only Hayate could save her from a destiny worse than death.
Genre: Romance, Fantasy, Adult
Pairing: Nanoha x Fate / Signum x Hayate
Just like in Tsuyazakura Kouyuki’s previous works, this is yet again a story in which love and the characters’ feelings for one another play the biggest role. To keep things interesting, there’s also a (so far) reasonable amount of drama nicely put into the story, which makes this one feel like an emotional rollercoaster.
For NanoFate fans, this is definitely a must-read. I swear their get-together in this one was so overwhelming and beautiful, that I feel the strong need to re-read this right now.
There are only 4 chapters out yet, but if this story manages to even get close to the awesomeness of his previous work “Lovers Eternal”, then I’m already in love, but for now let’s see how things continue.
Anime: Shingeki no Kyojin
Title: Bad Dog
Krista nearly hits a dog with her car during a storm and takes it home, only to find that it’s not just a dog, but a person named Ymir seemingly stuck within a curse.
Genre: Romance, Comedy, Supernatural
Pairing: Ymir x Christa
I just came across this one recently and fell in love with it at first sight. Other than the characters, this fanfiction has nothing in common with the Shingeki no Kyojin anime and manga. So you could say it’s a rather light and fun story that is quite easy to read and very entertaining on top of that. I think it’s still too early to really praise it that much, but so far, this is one of the best fanfiction I’ve read in a long while and fortunately updates come in like every 3 days, so the wait is never too long.
Anime: Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha
Title: Vampire Fate
Fate is a vampire with her sights set on a girl who is just trying to live her life normally. When their very different worlds collide, the two must find ways to accept each other and make it through their hardships.
Genre: Romance, Supernatural
Pairing: Nanoha x Fate
This is one of the most intriguing NanoFate fanfiction I’ve ever read, which is why the fact that this one will probably never be continued, let alone finished sucks so very much. Well I’m only basing this on the fact that the author hasn’t updated the story in like 5 years, so I guess it’s safe to say, that there won’t be more of it.
Such a pity, I really enjoyed the way the author presented their relationship and the fact that Fate is a vampire makes this whole story really great and maybe even sexy?
And yet again 2 fanfiction for those of you, who are interested in some adult works:
Anime: Mai Hime/Otome
Title: Birthday Puppy
Natsuki gives Shizuru a special treat for her birthday.
Pairing: Natsuki x Schizuru
Anime: Mai Hime/Otome
Title: Losing Grace
Shizuru returns after months away from Garderobe. After discovering her love is wounded, Natsuki wishes only to take all of it away.
Pairing: Natsuki x Shizuru
I know, I’ve only listed adult Mai Hime fanfiction. But then again, this is the only series I actually know to have good adult ones…
Other than that, I hope that this list was actual helpful to some of you and as always, feel free to let me know whether I missed something, it being adult or not doesn’t matter.